Saturday, November 21, 2009

Media Effects

At one end of the spectrum is the powerful effects model, which theorizes that receivers "are relatively passive; they accept media messages at face value and unconsciously allow media sources to tell them what to think." On the other hand, there is the limited effects model which theorizes that "audience members interpret messages according to their own preexisting beliefs and values and use these messages in unique ways" (pg. 303).

Although I believe we cannot fully escape the influence of media, my views are closer to the limited effects model. I believe that people rarely take anything they watch, hear, or read at face value, but at the same time, these things are not completely disregarded and often can change a person's opinion or views or lead them to want to learn more.

One day when I was watching TV, the talk show I was watching had a segment on this company called Kiva where you can make loans to citizens of third world countries to help them start their own businesses. At first I thought this sounded like a huge hoax, but I researched it and the company was actually very legitimate. As a poor college student I don't really have to means to participate however, this was an example to me of how the media can influence my beliefs and be a gateway for learning.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Medium

2). Do you agree with Marshall McLuhan that the medium is the message, i.e. that the format or logic of a medium is as important as its content and, in fact, determines what content will be broadcast through that channel? Evaluate his idea that television is a cool medium.

I feel like the medium you chose to send a message is like the nonverbal communication of f2f talking; included in this is that it needs to enhance the message not contradict it. I actually read an interesting study concering this topic for another class involving teacher/student communication in Japan and the United States. In this study the scientist were trying to figure out if college students in these two counties communicated through different mediums with their teacher because the have different concepts of power distance (United States tends to see people as equal whereas Japan places emphasis on a defined power structure). The conclusion was that Japanese students tend to communicate more through face to face interaction because they believe it shows more respect for their professors than say email or instant messaging whereas American students use email or instant messaging more because although they respect their professors, they are more concerned with saving time and convenience than with going out of their way to use more formal ways of communication.

I agree with McLuhan's interpretation of TV (and movies) as a cool medium. For instance, my friend is currently outraged that the Twilight movies don't follow the book exactly. However, in my opinion, not everything in a book can be translated into a movie. Thoughts, feelings, and situations can take tens of pages to explain in a book but with tv or a movie, no one wants to sit through a five hour movie where every detail is spelled out. Therefore I think TV is a cool medium because it requires its viewers to fill in between the lines.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

cyberspace

1). Have you made friendships that exist exclusively in cyberspace? If so, how are they different from f2f relationships? If you have not formed cyber relationships, why not?

I have never had a friendship that existed exclusively in cyberspace because I am generally an untrusting person and believe there are a lot of crazy people in this world. Even when it comes to Facebook or Myspace when they have pictures of 'themselves' and belong to a college network, I don't automatically believe they are who they say they are.

I have used cyberspace to grow aquaintences into friendships though. For instance, when I was 15 (obviously before I could drive) I really like this guy who I had met at a dance but he lived all the way in Hollister. Although we probably could have just talked on the phone, we ended up instant messaging for hours. Just like texting, instant messaging is a good way to get to know someone because it doesn't have that conversational pressure like talking f2f or over the phone and you can talk to someone all day because they dont expect an immediate reply and you can do other things while messaging.

Saturday, November 7, 2009

Self-disclosure

Overall I really enjoyed reading chapter six because I felt like I could directly apply most of the concepts to the relationships and events that are going on in my life right now. One concept that I have heard a lot since I started taking COMM classes is self-disclosure. As Trenholm states, self-disclosure is "the voluntary revealing of information that would normally be unobtainable."

Although you shouldnt disclose everything about your life the instant you meet someone, having someone who you can be completely open with is what I believe to be one of the most gratifying aspects of a relationship. However, I have also found that the expressive-protective dialectic can be a very tricky to balance, especially with romantic partners. Once I dated a guy who kept a lot to himself and it drove me nuts because I am the opposite and generally when you disclose part of yourself to someone, you expect them to disclose back. After learning about self-disclosure in a class last spring it made me realize that self-disclosure is directly linked to vulnerability and although I may feel comfortable putting myself out there, I can't expect everyone I meet to feel the same and that I needed to learn how to encourage disclosure without demanding it as I was doing with the guy I was dating.

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Filters

Of course their is an obvious qualification of physical attractiveness, but more than that, I think a person's personality or character traits are what really make them attractive or unattractive. Some things that turn me off to a guy is bad personal hygiene, a need to control me, a guy who can't make me laugh or only makes jokes at other people's expense, or a guy that has no ambitions in life.

Ducks theory makes sense to me but at the same time I don't always agree with order that he puts them in. For example, I once met a guy who I thought was attractive, we got along great, and who I had lots in common with. His only downfall was that he lived 45 minutes away. However, this did not stop me initially from wanting to get to know him but after a couple months, it became such a hassle that we decided it was just not going to work. Another example of an experience I had where I rearranged Duck's filters is when I ruled out a guy as a potential love interest because I wasn't initially physically attracted to him but later, after I got to know him as a friend, became so attracted to him that we started dating.

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Patterns

Personally, I think rigid complementarity would be the hardest to change because it is developed over a period of time and seems to be more set in stone than competitive or submissive symmetry. Also, from the reading, I get the sense that rigid complementarity is just given and not really open for discussion, such as a parents' relationship to a child. Although eventually the son or daughter will gain independence from the parent, it is a long process and as any son or daughter knows, is often a struggle especially in the teenage years.

I think submissive symmetry would be most damaging to a relationship because both people are fighting for control by not taking any control. In my experience, trying to date a person who never has a preference or opinion on anything gets old really fast and makes me think that they just don't care about anything, including me.

Competitive symmetry would be potentially the most damaging to the self-esteem of the individuals involved because when two people are in a competition (such as a competition for power) there is always a winner and a loser. Also, in the spirit of competition, often times people are harsher or employ tactics that they wouldn't have in a normal situation because they just want to win or be right.

Saturday, October 24, 2009

individualism/collectivism

For my third post this week I would like to relate the idea of individualism and collectivism (found on page 353) to an interesting journal article I read titled “Can dimensions of national culture predict cross-national differences in medical communication?” found in the journal patient education and counseling. In the article, researchers did a study in ten different European countries (all of which of were characterized by a different level of individualism/collectivism) and tried to find how individualism/collectivism influences patients’ experiences with doctor visits. The conclusion was that in countries characterized by a high level of collectivism, patients were more satisfied overall compared to patients in individualist countries. This finding is attributed to the fact that in collectivist countries, doctor’s and patient’s roles are relatively fixed, which led to a positive relationship between what patients expected to happen and what actually happened in their visits. Because collectivist cultures are also more comfortable with vertical relationships, patients tend to question doctors less because of their status, which was also found to positively influence a patience experience.