Tuesday, December 8, 2009

post #, week 12/6-8

One aspect of this class that I especially enjoyed is the way in which I still get to interact with my peers even though it is an online class. In fact, I think I have interacted with all of you More than in a normal lecture where I just go, sit, listen, and leave. Another aspect of this class that I liked is how all of the assignments served to enhance my knowledge of the concepts. I didn’t think there was anything we did that was just “busy work.”

On that same note though, I did feel that our final paper and journal entries were kind of one of the same. I know professor Perez just wanted us to find examples of the concepts in the book in our everyday lives and in a fictional piece of media, but I felt like many of the concepts that I analyzed in my journal entries, I also analyzed in my final paper. Although I didn’t think the work load was too overbearing, I think this class could do without the last paper.

post #2 week 12/6-8

Although I think this is one of the better communication studies books I’ve read in terms of being thorough and covering all aspects of communication, the one chapter I didn’t feel was very insightful was ch. 12, intercultural communication. Maybe it’s because I’ve taken two other classes that are purely on intercultural communication, but this is the one chapter I feel I didn’t learn much from. As far as a specific concept that needs more discussion, I cannot think of any concept that I felt like I didn’t understand, however, I would like to learn more concepts about intercultural communication than the ones I read over and over (ie collectivism, and stereotypes). Although other parts of the country may benefit from the information in ch. 12, I feel that here in Silicon Valley, it takes some very insightful information about intercultural communication to teach us more than what we can learn just by interacting with the people around us.

Post #1, week 12/6-8

1). What concept/s in this class have you found most interesting? What was it about the concept/s that you found interesting.

The two overarching topics that I found most interesting in this class are the topics of interpersonal communication and mass media communication. The first, interpersonal communication I find has the most use in my every-day and professional life. Additionally I feel as though interpersonal communication incorporates many of the other types of communication such as nonverbal, verbal, and the concept of listening. Another aspect of interpersonal communication that I think I particularly enjoy is how it delves into ways in which we can improve our relationships with others. While reading chapter six I feel like I was constantly comparing the concepts in my head to the relationships I have already established. Specifically, I like what Trenholm had to say about managing conflict and I found the section on relational development very eye opening.

My second favorite topic would have to be ch. 11, communication and the mass media. Popular culture has always been something that interests me and I feel that this chapter’s analysis of media was thorough and insightful. I had never really thought about how the “medium is the message,” but now that I have a better understanding of how each type of media lends to communication, I definitely agree with this statement.

Saturday, November 21, 2009

Media Effects

At one end of the spectrum is the powerful effects model, which theorizes that receivers "are relatively passive; they accept media messages at face value and unconsciously allow media sources to tell them what to think." On the other hand, there is the limited effects model which theorizes that "audience members interpret messages according to their own preexisting beliefs and values and use these messages in unique ways" (pg. 303).

Although I believe we cannot fully escape the influence of media, my views are closer to the limited effects model. I believe that people rarely take anything they watch, hear, or read at face value, but at the same time, these things are not completely disregarded and often can change a person's opinion or views or lead them to want to learn more.

One day when I was watching TV, the talk show I was watching had a segment on this company called Kiva where you can make loans to citizens of third world countries to help them start their own businesses. At first I thought this sounded like a huge hoax, but I researched it and the company was actually very legitimate. As a poor college student I don't really have to means to participate however, this was an example to me of how the media can influence my beliefs and be a gateway for learning.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Medium

2). Do you agree with Marshall McLuhan that the medium is the message, i.e. that the format or logic of a medium is as important as its content and, in fact, determines what content will be broadcast through that channel? Evaluate his idea that television is a cool medium.

I feel like the medium you chose to send a message is like the nonverbal communication of f2f talking; included in this is that it needs to enhance the message not contradict it. I actually read an interesting study concering this topic for another class involving teacher/student communication in Japan and the United States. In this study the scientist were trying to figure out if college students in these two counties communicated through different mediums with their teacher because the have different concepts of power distance (United States tends to see people as equal whereas Japan places emphasis on a defined power structure). The conclusion was that Japanese students tend to communicate more through face to face interaction because they believe it shows more respect for their professors than say email or instant messaging whereas American students use email or instant messaging more because although they respect their professors, they are more concerned with saving time and convenience than with going out of their way to use more formal ways of communication.

I agree with McLuhan's interpretation of TV (and movies) as a cool medium. For instance, my friend is currently outraged that the Twilight movies don't follow the book exactly. However, in my opinion, not everything in a book can be translated into a movie. Thoughts, feelings, and situations can take tens of pages to explain in a book but with tv or a movie, no one wants to sit through a five hour movie where every detail is spelled out. Therefore I think TV is a cool medium because it requires its viewers to fill in between the lines.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

cyberspace

1). Have you made friendships that exist exclusively in cyberspace? If so, how are they different from f2f relationships? If you have not formed cyber relationships, why not?

I have never had a friendship that existed exclusively in cyberspace because I am generally an untrusting person and believe there are a lot of crazy people in this world. Even when it comes to Facebook or Myspace when they have pictures of 'themselves' and belong to a college network, I don't automatically believe they are who they say they are.

I have used cyberspace to grow aquaintences into friendships though. For instance, when I was 15 (obviously before I could drive) I really like this guy who I had met at a dance but he lived all the way in Hollister. Although we probably could have just talked on the phone, we ended up instant messaging for hours. Just like texting, instant messaging is a good way to get to know someone because it doesn't have that conversational pressure like talking f2f or over the phone and you can talk to someone all day because they dont expect an immediate reply and you can do other things while messaging.

Saturday, November 7, 2009

Self-disclosure

Overall I really enjoyed reading chapter six because I felt like I could directly apply most of the concepts to the relationships and events that are going on in my life right now. One concept that I have heard a lot since I started taking COMM classes is self-disclosure. As Trenholm states, self-disclosure is "the voluntary revealing of information that would normally be unobtainable."

Although you shouldnt disclose everything about your life the instant you meet someone, having someone who you can be completely open with is what I believe to be one of the most gratifying aspects of a relationship. However, I have also found that the expressive-protective dialectic can be a very tricky to balance, especially with romantic partners. Once I dated a guy who kept a lot to himself and it drove me nuts because I am the opposite and generally when you disclose part of yourself to someone, you expect them to disclose back. After learning about self-disclosure in a class last spring it made me realize that self-disclosure is directly linked to vulnerability and although I may feel comfortable putting myself out there, I can't expect everyone I meet to feel the same and that I needed to learn how to encourage disclosure without demanding it as I was doing with the guy I was dating.

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Filters

Of course their is an obvious qualification of physical attractiveness, but more than that, I think a person's personality or character traits are what really make them attractive or unattractive. Some things that turn me off to a guy is bad personal hygiene, a need to control me, a guy who can't make me laugh or only makes jokes at other people's expense, or a guy that has no ambitions in life.

Ducks theory makes sense to me but at the same time I don't always agree with order that he puts them in. For example, I once met a guy who I thought was attractive, we got along great, and who I had lots in common with. His only downfall was that he lived 45 minutes away. However, this did not stop me initially from wanting to get to know him but after a couple months, it became such a hassle that we decided it was just not going to work. Another example of an experience I had where I rearranged Duck's filters is when I ruled out a guy as a potential love interest because I wasn't initially physically attracted to him but later, after I got to know him as a friend, became so attracted to him that we started dating.

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Patterns

Personally, I think rigid complementarity would be the hardest to change because it is developed over a period of time and seems to be more set in stone than competitive or submissive symmetry. Also, from the reading, I get the sense that rigid complementarity is just given and not really open for discussion, such as a parents' relationship to a child. Although eventually the son or daughter will gain independence from the parent, it is a long process and as any son or daughter knows, is often a struggle especially in the teenage years.

I think submissive symmetry would be most damaging to a relationship because both people are fighting for control by not taking any control. In my experience, trying to date a person who never has a preference or opinion on anything gets old really fast and makes me think that they just don't care about anything, including me.

Competitive symmetry would be potentially the most damaging to the self-esteem of the individuals involved because when two people are in a competition (such as a competition for power) there is always a winner and a loser. Also, in the spirit of competition, often times people are harsher or employ tactics that they wouldn't have in a normal situation because they just want to win or be right.

Saturday, October 24, 2009

individualism/collectivism

For my third post this week I would like to relate the idea of individualism and collectivism (found on page 353) to an interesting journal article I read titled “Can dimensions of national culture predict cross-national differences in medical communication?” found in the journal patient education and counseling. In the article, researchers did a study in ten different European countries (all of which of were characterized by a different level of individualism/collectivism) and tried to find how individualism/collectivism influences patients’ experiences with doctor visits. The conclusion was that in countries characterized by a high level of collectivism, patients were more satisfied overall compared to patients in individualist countries. This finding is attributed to the fact that in collectivist countries, doctor’s and patient’s roles are relatively fixed, which led to a positive relationship between what patients expected to happen and what actually happened in their visits. Because collectivist cultures are also more comfortable with vertical relationships, patients tend to question doctors less because of their status, which was also found to positively influence a patience experience.

Friday, October 23, 2009

Premises

I would say that I believe in two out of the three premises outlined in our text. I believe the rationality premise and the mutability premise, but I am doubtful about the perfectibility premise. I’m not especially religious and don’t believe in ‘original sin.’ Instead, I generally believe that people are good and born without sin; however, there is always room for improvement and I think through effort and control, people can do a lot of good and become better persons.
As far as institutions and practices based on these beliefs, I think the rationality premise underlies democracy, the stock market, and even our system of traffic signs and signals as we trust people that have licenses to be able to make good decisions (such as to stop at a light when it’s red) while driving. The perfectibility premise mainly underlies most religions, but also underlies practices that are thought to enhance control and discipline such as meditation, school, and even sports. Lastly, the mutability premise underlies such things as our countries welfare program, the belief in universal health care, and public works projects.

Thursday, October 22, 2009

Creatures of our Culture

I agree to some extent with Ruth Benedict's statement that we are "creatures of our culture." However, for people like me who don't really feel like they belong to any one culture, I'd say that factors such as life experiences have shaped me a lot more than 'culture.' My habits, beliefs, and impossibilities were first influenced by my parents but then as I grew older my peers, teachers, and personal experiences pretty much shaped who I am today. The problem with the world 'culture,' is that almost anything can be described as a culture. For instance I belong to a student culture, a california culture, a white anglo-saxon middle class culture, a female culture, etc. which definately all have influenced me in some way or another but to say that I am a "creature of my culture" is taking it a little too far for me.

The second part of our prompt asks us "how can we break through the limits of our cultures?" I would answer that in order to do this, a person should include themselves in more than one culture. This way, we have lots of channels of influence and are not limited by any one belief, attitude, or way of life.

Saturday, October 10, 2009

Time Orientation

One part of this chapter I find particularly interesting is the section on time. For another class I'm in this semester we are required to read Edward T. Hall's "The Dance of Life, The Other Dimensions of Time," where Hall introduces the concept that there is such thing as more than one kind of time.

As far as Gonzalez and Zimbardo's time perspectives go, I think the perspective I relate to most is the 'Future, daily planning' perspective. As the book states on page 123, these respondents "are obsessed with controlling the details of day-to-day events. They are the list makers and daily planners who map out their lives in specific detail." I actually laughed when I read this because I am such a list maker. I even have a sheet of paper pinned to the message board in my room where I wrote down my daily goals in terms of hours (i.e. sleep for 8 hours, do homework for 3 hours, exercise for 1 hour, etc.). Although I like spontaneity and doing random fun things, they are still usually somehow scheduled. For example Wednesdays are my fun days. Since I don't have work and only an hour of class on Wednesdays I usually plan to do something fun on those days. I always kind of thought of list makers as people who like to control, but I think the main reason I have this time perspective is that I like the feeling I get when I accomplish a personal goal and writing a list of things to do everyday is like accomplishing lots of mini goals.

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Nonverbal displays

Honestly, trying to write this post made me realize that I seriously need to travel more!!! I've lived in the same house my whole life and the farthest away I've ever been is Puerta Vallarta, Mexico so it's kind of hard for me to think of example of places where nonverbal messages mean something different besides the ones everyone else already knows or the examples they gave in the book. However, I did talk to some of my friends and one brought up a sign that I didn't even know existed!

Apparently, in France pulling down the bottom of your eyelid so the pink part shows communicates that you don't believe what the other person is telling you. So for example if I was talking to some guy and he was telling me about how he saw a real, live, pink elephant yesterday I would stare at him and pull down my bottom eyelid! This sounds a little strange (and kinda gross) but I guess that's just because I'm not used to it.

Another example I though of from my brief international travels is staring. Here in the U.S., staring is considered very rude and if someone is staring at you it either means they want to pick a fight or they're trying to disrespect you in some form. However, I've noticed in the part of Mexico that my family always goes to, that it isn't such a big deal. I can't really say if this is true for the whole country, but at our condo I've noticed that people just stare at each other and no one gets offended. At first I thought it was just because I looked like a tourist, but there are a lot of Americans there and it's not like I really stand out that much.

Have you ever noticed either of these two nonverbal disparities? Let me know!

Monday, October 5, 2009

Nonverbal Communication

As a nanny of two-year old twins, I rely on nonverbal communication everyday in order to do my job. Sure they scream and laugh and that gives me a big hint of what they like or want, but when the little girl is in her crib screaming what sounds like DIAPERS (which means she wants her teddy bear), nonverbal communication sure comes in handy.

Although in the past six months or so they have gotten pretty good at trying to verbalize what they want, paying attention to their nonverbal signals is what helps me the most; however, I don't always interpret them correctly. I remember this one day the little boy had his hand up by his head and was opening and closing his hand while making clicking sounds. It looked like he was waving bye to something but was getting frustrated that I didn't know what he wanted. I later learned that his mom had been teaching him baby sign language and that was in fact the sign for 'horse.' He had wanted to sit on his toy horse which his mom had just moved to the other room.

I feel like the best way to be accurate in our readings of nonverbal messages is to pay attention to the context they are in. This includes being aware of your surroundings (such as noticing what toy's got moved where), and trying to match the nonverbal messages to the verbal ones. With these other clues to help, I feel it is much easier to interpret other's nonverbal messages correctly.

Saturday, October 3, 2009

Ambiguity

"Does this dress make me look fat?" ...the ultimate question for an ambiguous answer. As our book states on pg. 98, "Clarity is not always advantageous, even in a low-context culture like ours, and ambiguity can sometimes help, rather than hinder, communication." Although in general I think people should tell the truth, there is a time and place for everything including ambiguity; that is as long as it's done tactfully and sincerely.

The other reason I find ambiguity useful besides to avoid offending people is when someone makes me give an answer that I don't want to be held to. I don't know if anyone else has a friend like this, but I once had this friend who would remember Everything I said, word-for-word, and then feel free to use it to his advantage. Believe me, I became a master of saying ambiguous things in that relationship! Although this sounds a bit manipulative, politicians and other formal institutions do it all the time, especially when put on the spot and not given enough time to think about the answer they really want to be held to.

So in conclusion, although I advocate telling the truth, I believe ambiguous speech definitely has a valid place in communication.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Men are From Mars!

In general, I feel that gender does have an effect on language and the way men and women talk differ. Two differences that I feel are particularly true are the differences in Quantity of talk and Self-disclosure. One point that our book brings up on table 4.5 that I have found to be particularly true is that "In friendly same-gender dyads, women prefer to spend time talking; men prefer to share activities such as sports and hobbies." I know that with my girlfriends, I am totally fine just meeting up to talk, usually over lunch or coffee, but the main activity is just talking. However, if I guy asks one of his other guy friends out to lunch to chat, this could be considered abnormal. Usually the talking is done at a sports game and at least with a few beers.

The second difference that I have found to be true with my interactions with men is they tend to self-disclose less, especially when not prompted to do so. Although I now realize that this is what their gender roles have taught them to do, I admittedly still get annoyed when something is bothering my boyfriend and he cannot for the life of him tell me what's wrong.

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Judgment Day

In our first prompt we are asked, "is it possible to perceive others without in some way judging or cateorizing them?" My answer is not really, but I don't necessarily think that this is a bad thing. Although people shouldn't only care about what others think of them or how they are perceived, I believe each person on this planet has in their mind what they want to be/ how they want others to perceive them and work hard to communicate this through the way they dress, walk, talk, style their hair etc. I'm a big fan of Erving Goffman's theory of performativity which states that we have a public and private self and that public self that 99% of the people we come into contact with see is specifically determined by our own actions. We are the actor and life is the stage.

However, I think the most rewarding thing is to become that 1% of people that get to see someone else's private or "backstage" self which is really only accomplished when we push past someone's public facade to find out who they really are. Although I think we automatically compartmentalize people upon first meeting to get a better understanding of them, I think Judgement should be reserved only for people that you have taken the time to actually get to know.

As far of the second part of this question, "how can we make the judgements we do make more fair?" I would say we can be more fair by being open and understanding that no two people are the same; so even if the are in the same "compartment" with someone else we highly dislike, disliking someone just because they are (for example) platinum blonde is very superficial and we could be missing out on our new best friend or life lover if we only rely on people's public "performance" to make a judgement about them.

Friday, September 11, 2009

Defining Communication

Out of all the definitions in Table 2.1 (page 20) I think the one I identify most with is definition #6, "Communication is a process whereby people assign meanings to stimuli in order to make sense of the world." As Trenholm states, "people who take this view prefer that the definition of communication include unintentional as well as intentional behaviors."

Although something I wish people wouldn't pick up on my unintentional behaviors, I think it is a big part of understanding someone else. Unintentional communication is why I can tell when my best friend is upset even though she is smiling (her eyebrows always pinch together when she's upset) and why professional detectives can tell when people are lying (again from unintentional physical cues). If we always disregarded the unintentional aspect of communication, then I think we would miss out on a lot the actual meanings of messages we receive. I don't know if anyone else likes to people watch, but you can sure learn a lot about humanity just by sitting on a bench in the mall and watch what people are doing.

Thursday, September 10, 2009

The Pragmatic Perspective

Personally, I think it makes sense to think of communication as patterned interaction. For instance, at work yesterday I was supposed to call all my customers and remind them of this promotion we are having. Knowing that I usually get tongue tied when talking to people I don't really know I jotted down points for me to talk about however, although those notes came in handy when the person didn't pick up and I had to leave a message, when they did pick up those notes went out the window because what they said always through me off course.

Like a game of chess, I believe what "moves" a person makes in his or her communication with another person depends a lot on situation at hand and what the other person has just said or nonverbally expressed. For instance, you had a great day and can't wait to come home and tell your significant other all about it but when you walk in the door she is crying because her cat got hit by a car. Are you still going to walk in there and cheerfully tell her about your great day? Not unless you want to be acused of being terribly insensitive and get the silent treatment for the next two days. Instead you will drop what you wanted to say and (hopefully) comfort her.

The only way I think communication differs from a game is that there is usually no winner. There may be a winner if you are having an argument with another person, but on a day to day basis, the goal of communication, unlike the goal of a game, is not to win something.

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

The Social Constructionist Perspective

On page 30 Trenholm exclaims, "This [the social constructionist perspective] points out that most of what we know and believe about the world comes to us through communication rather than through direct experience. If everyone around us talks about the world in a certain way, we are likely to think of the world in that way and fail to question whether we are seeing things accurately."

One concept in particular came to mind as I was reading our first posting prompt and that was the concept of individuality. Not only is the culture of the United States very individualistic, but the beliefs I was raised on further emphasized the concept of "everyone for themselves." I'm not saying that my parents were selfish or didn't care for me, but there was always that understanding within my family that if you want to get somewhere in life you and you alone have to make it happen.

This idea of taking personal responsibility for your life has proved successful so far; I work hard to get what I want but also try not to step on too many people to get there. As far as happiness, I wish people would help each other out a little more. Although I'm first to admit I'm usually looking out for #1, I wish I lived in a place where everyone would help each other and no one selfishly took advantage of it. I know that sounds like Communism but we all know how well that turned out...

Saturday, September 5, 2009

The teachings of George Campbell

According to Trenholdm, "One of Campbell's most modern ideas concerned the relationship between speaker and audience. He believed that receivers were active participants in the persuasion process and that the effective communicator studied the inner workings or "faculties," of the human mind" (pg. 11)

In an interpersonal communication class I took last spring, the book we used talked a lot about being an "other-oriented" communicator. I think this is a very important concept because people interpret messages according to their beliefs, values, culture etc. and it is crucial for the sender of the message to take their listeners point of view into account in order to formulate their message in a way that will make the meaning of their message transmit successfully.

Therefore, if we can do as Campbell advises and study the "inner workings" of the receivers mind, we will be better communicators than if we only tailor our messages according to our own personal experiences and motivations.

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

Question Everything!

So our prompt was "the greeks believed that to be an orator, an individual had to be morally good." Now traditionally someone who is considered an orator is more than just a person talking; it is a person who is known for their speeches because they inspire and persuade with examples like MLK jr., Thomas Paine or (I hate to say it) Adolf Hitler.

This last example brings me to my point of a person definitely does not have to be morally good to be an orator however, I believe it is a lot easier to be a successful (meaning your speeches inspire and persuade) orator if the person and their ideas are seen as morally good.

As far as the connection between truth and public speaking, especially in the present where information is so readily available, I believe the absence of truth can cause an orator to lose a lot of their credibility, a quality that I believe is essential if one wants to be inspiring and persuasive.
This makes me draw the conclusion that the inclusion of truth (including half-truths) is more crucial to an orator than to be morally good.

Monday, August 31, 2009

Motivational Speaker

This past summer I had an internship with the company Nordstrom. Although most of the internship involved selling, I also had the chance to hear from a lot of the people at the top of the company such as Delena Sunday who is head of Human Resources and Diversity Affairs. Out of all the speakers I heard from in those two months I think I found Mrs. Sunday the most motivating and persuasive because of her personal character or ethos.

Besides her obvious authority as the head of HR, Sunday also established credibility with her audience by giving us her ladder of progression throughout the company. In addition, because she started at the bottom in the stock room and made her way to the top, it gave her audience the feeling that she knew what she was talking about and it her more relatable than someone who had never been a stock room worker or a salesperson before.

I think my strongest ability to persuade comes from the fact that I am very analytical. For instance, if I am trying to prove a point I like to gather as many different pieces of information as I can, organize them in a logical order, and then present them all at once. According to Aristotle's classifications, this would mean that I mainly depend on pathos to persuade.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Introduction

Hey everyone!

I am currently a senior at SJSU working towards a B.A. in communication studies with a minor in business. Like most of you, I have switched majors a couple times in the past four years but decided on communication studies because it didn't completely bore me to death like the business major did but it is applicable to a wider range of careers than an art degree.

I decided to take a couple of online classes this semester because I took org. comm over the summer online and really like how it was set up and how straight forward it was. Like this class, we had to set up a blog and post about various topics from the book. I decided on this class specifically because not only does it address theory and research, but also because I am interested in learning more about how our surroundings effect how we interact/communication interpersonally as well as on a larger scale.

Having taken quite a few communication classes in the past few years I would have to say that Performance Communication has been my favorite class so far. Maybe it's because I secretly want to be an actress some day or maybe it's because I had Jake (professor Simmons) as my teacher for that class but that is what got me really hooked on comm studies. If you get the chance, I highly recommend you take some sort of performance communication class just because it is communication in such a different form from the rest.

I look forward to reading all of your blog posts and hopefully I will write something you find insightful or worthwhile!

-Commeleon